Navigating Shared Grief: When Names Overlap in Pregnancy

Therapy Talk: Unlocking Answers in 'Ask a Therapist'


Welcome to our blog series, where we delve into the human experiences that shape our emotional landscapes. In this edition, we address a heartfelt question from a reader who is struggling with the emotional aftermath of a miscarriage.

Hey Therapist Talk,

So, here's the deal: I went through a really tough miscarriage, and my partner and I had already picked out a name for our baby. But guess what? My sister-in-law just dropped the bombshell that she's pregnant too and wants to use the exact same name! Can you believe it? I'm feeling so hurt, broken, and seriously stressed about family get-togethers. I don't know how to approach her about this without causing more drama. How do I find some healing and resolution here?
Thanks a ton, P

Dear P,
Thank you for reaching out and sharing your heartfelt concerns. We appreciate your openness and trust in seeking guidance. We want to acknowledge the pain and frustration you're currently experiencing. How incredibly tough when someone close to us does something so hurtful like choosing the same name for their child after we've already chosen it for ours. In this blog, we will delve into the topic of unexpected overlap of names in pregnancy. Our aim is to provide valuable insights and practical guidance to help you navigate this challenging situation with understanding and resilience. Stay tuned as we explore hope for finding resolution and empowerment in this challenging situation.
Warm Regards, The RAFT Team

When Pregnancy Names Collide


Experiencing a miscarriage is a profound loss that can have a lasting impact on an individual's emotional well-being. The reader's situation highlights the added complexity of having already chosen a name for the child. The act of naming holds significant meaning and symbolizes the bond formed with the unborn child. When someone else, especially a family member, chooses the same name, it can feel like a painful reminder of the loss and intensify the grieving process.

Coping with Unresolved Grief

After a miscarriage, grief is a natural response as individuals mourn the loss of their hopes, dreams, and the future they had envisioned with their child. It is essential to recognize that grief is a unique and personal journey, and there is no set timeline for healing. Unresolved grief can manifest in various ways, including feelings of sadness, anger, guilt, or a sense of emptiness. It is crucial to allow yourself to grieve and seek support to navigate this challenging emotional terrain.

Emotional Turmoil and Anxiety

The reader's feelings of hurt, brokenness, and anxiety surrounding family gatherings are understandable given the circumstances. Seeing the sister-in-law's pregnancy announcement and her intention to use the same name can trigger a range of emotions, including anxiety about facing reminders of the reader's own loss. The anticipation of family gatherings may amplify these emotions, leading to increased stress and anxiety.

It's important to acknowledge that these emotional responses are valid and natural. However, it is equally important to find healthy coping mechanisms to manage anxiety and prevent it from overwhelming daily life. Seeking support and implementing self-care practices can play a vital role in alleviating emotional turmoil and fostering resilience.

Approaching the Sister-in-Law: Acknowledging Your Emotions

The first step in addressing the situation with your sister-in-law is to acknowledge and validate your own emotions. It's completely understandable to feel hurt, broken, and even a sense of betrayal in this situation. Allow yourself the space to grieve and process these emotions without judgment. Recognize that your feelings are valid and deserving of attention and care. Give yourself permission to explore and understand the depth of your emotions surrounding the overlap of names.

Empathy and Open Communication

Approaching your sister-in-law with empathy and open communication can lay the foundation for a constructive conversation. Consider that she may not be aware of the emotional impact her choice of name has on you. It's important to approach the conversation from a place of understanding and compassion. Choose a suitable time and setting where both of you can have a calm and uninterrupted dialogue.

Express your feelings honestly and respectfully, focusing on the impact her decision has had on your emotional well-being. Use "I" statements to convey your own experience without placing blame. For example, instead of saying, "You shouldn't have chosen that name," say, "I feel hurt and it brings up painful memories when I learned that you chose the same name." By expressing your emotions authentically, you create an opportunity for your sister-in-law to understand your perspective.

Setting Boundaries and Expectations

When discussing the situation, it's important to set clear boundaries and establish realistic expectations moving forward. Consider what would bring you a sense of resolution and comfort in this situation. Communicate your needs openly and assertively, while also being willing to listen to your sister-in-law's perspective.

For example, you may express that you would appreciate it if she could acknowledge your experience and the significance of the name you had chosen. It's essential to emphasize that you understand she has the right to choose the name she desires, but it would mean a lot to you if she could recognize the emotional impact it has on you. Discussing your boundaries and expectations openly can help foster understanding and pave the way for finding a mutually respectful resolution.


When navigating complex emotional situations like these, professional counseling in Parker CO can provide valuable guidance. Relationship counseling can help you develop effective communication skills and foster empathy in challenging conversations. It offers a safe space to explore and express your emotions while finding ways to set healthy boundaries and establish realistic expectations. At RAFT Counseling, our therapists specialize in anxiety treatment, mental health, and relationship counseling, providing support tailored to your unique needs as you navigate this sensitive situation.

Navigating Family Gatherings and Beyond: Preparing for Family Events

When faced with upcoming family events where you may encounter your sister-in-law, it's important to take proactive steps to prepare yourself emotionally. Consider engaging in self-care practices that help ground and center you before these gatherings. This may include activities such as meditation, deep breathing exercises, or engaging in hobbies that bring you joy and relaxation.

Additionally, having a support system in place can be immensely helpful. Reach out to trusted friends or family members who can provide understanding and reassurance during these events. Communicate your feelings and concerns to them so that they can offer support and be there for you when needed.

Finding Inner Strength

Amidst the emotional challenges you're facing, it's crucial to tap into your inner strength and resilience. Reflect on the ways you have overcome adversity in the past and draw upon those experiences to remind yourself of your resilience. Engage in positive self-talk and affirmations to boost your confidence and belief in your ability to navigate through difficult situations.

Engaging in activities that foster self-empowerment, such as practicing mindfulness, journaling, or engaging in creative outlets, can also help you reconnect with your inner strength. These practices allow you to cultivate a sense of self-awareness and promote emotional well-being.

Fostering Connection and Understanding

While it may initially seem challenging, fostering connection and understanding with your sister-in-law is a valuable goal to work towards. Seek to find common ground and shared experiences that can serve as a foundation for empathy and connection. Look for opportunities to engage in activities or conversations that allow you to bond and build a deeper understanding of each other's perspectives.

Remember, both you and your sister-in-law may be experiencing a range of emotions during this time, and open-mindedness and compassion can go a long way in fostering understanding. Building bridges of connection can create a more supportive and harmonious family environment for everyone involved.

In the context of counseling in Parker CO, these strategies can be supported by therapy sessions focused on building resilience, fostering emotional well-being, and enhancing relationship dynamics. At RAFT Counseling, our team of experts offers specialized services in anxiety treatment, mental health, and relationship counseling. Through therapeutic interventions tailored to your needs, you can develop strategies to prepare for family events, tap into your inner strength, and foster connection and understanding. Our goal is to empower you with the tools to navigate these challenges and find a path towards healing and growth.

In conclusion, the journey of healing after a miscarriage is a deeply personal and complex one. When faced with the unexpected overlap of names, it is crucial to acknowledge your emotions and prioritize self-care. Open communication, empathy, and setting healthy boundaries are essential in approaching your sister-in-law. Seeking professional support through counseling in Parker CO can provide valuable guidance and healing during this challenging time. Remember, you have the strength within you to navigate through this emotional terrain and find a path to resolution and peace.

We hope that this comprehensive guide has offered you solace and empowered you with the tools to address this challenging situation. Remember, you are not alone in your journey, and there is support available to help you find your way through the emotional complexities that arise. If we can help, reach out to us today.

Go Back